The Way And Its Power

In this talk Alan Watts describes nature as a self regulating, democratic totality that Taoism calls the Tao, and explains that following the way means acting along the grain of things rather than against them. He introduces Wu Wei, the principle of not forcing, illustrated with the image of jiggling a stubborn key rather than forcing a lock, and extends it to an ecological vision in which predation and symbiosis alike are forms of mutual cooperation rather than competition. Watts then turns to the word li, originally the markings in jade or the grain in wood, later used in Neo Confucian and Buddhist thought to describe an organic order that cannot be reduced to a rule or method, which is why creativity can be encouraged but never taught as a technique. He links this to the character xuan, the deep and mysterious, and to the Japanese term yuugen, quoting the Noh playwright Soami and a Chinese poem about a hermit sage who has gone herb gathering, his whereabouts unknown. Watts contrasts this trust in spontaneous, unprescribed order with the Western anxiety that nothing can be done properly without explicit instructions, a habit he traces half seriously to toilet training and caps with an anecdote about a hotel constipation class chanting "we haven't today, but we will tomorrow." The talk closes by urging the listener to let things happen and trust the organism to fulfill itself spontaneously, without forcing the outcome.
transcriptmachine-transcribed, unedited
So then, the whole conception of nature is as a self-regulating, self-governing, indeed
democratic organism.
But it has a totality.
It all goes together and this totality is the Tao.
When we speak in Taoism of following the course of nature, following the way, what it means
is more like this.
Doing things in accordance with the grain.
It doesn't mean you don't cut wood, but it means that you cut wood along the lines where
wood is most easy to cut.
And you interact with other people along lines which are the most genial.
And this then is the great fundamental principle, which is called Wu Wei.
Not to force anything.
I think that's the best translation.
It's often called not doing, not acting, not interfering, but not to force.
Seems to me to hit the nail on the head.
Like don't ever force a lock, or you bend the key or break the lock.
You jiggle until it revolves.
So Wu Wei is always to act in accordance with the pattern of things as they exist.
Don't impose on any situation a kind of interference that is not really in accordance with the
situation.
It would be better to do nothing than to interfere without knowing the system of relations that
exists.
It's terribly important then to have this feeling of the interdependence of every form
of life upon every other form of life.
How we for example cultivate animals that we eat, look after them and build them up
and see that they breed in reasonable quantities.
We don't do it too well as a matter of fact, especially troubles arising about supplies
of fish in the ocean.
All sorts of things.
But you have to see that life, that the so-called conflict of various species with each other
is not actually a competition.
It's a very strange system of interrelationship.
Of things feeding on each other and cultivating each other at the same time.
The idea of the friendly enemy.
The necessary adversary.
Who is part of you.
You have conflicts going on in your own body.
All kinds of microorganisms are eating each other up.
And if that wasn't happening you wouldn't be healthy.
So all those interrelationships, whether they appear to be friendly relationships as between
bees and flowers, or conflicting relationships as between birds and worms, they are actually
forms of cooperation.
And that is mutual arising.
You have to understand this as the basis, apply this not forcing anything, and you get
spontaneity.
A life which is so of itself, which is natural, which is not forced, which is not unduly self-conscious.
Now another term that is important, although I'm not aware that this word occurs in Lauser's
book, it's found in greater use at a much later time in Chinese thought, in a philosophy
that is called Neo-Confucian.
And it's also used in Buddhism.
But it is a very useful word for understanding the sort of order that all this constitutes.
It's the word "li".
And this means, originally, the markings in jade, or perhaps the grain in wood or the
fibre in muscle.
It is translated nowadays in most dictionaries as "reason" or "principle".
But this isn't a very good translation.
Joseph Needham suggested that "organic pattern" was an ideal translation for this word.
And so in the same way the foam patterns, the rock patterns, the patterns of vegetation
are once extraordinarily orderly, but they don't have an obvious order.
Nobody can ever pin it down, that's what I'd like to say.
You know that there is order there, there's something quite different from a mess, but
there's no way of really getting it.
Now in order to be able to paint that sort of way, or to live that sort of way, or to
deliver justice that way, if you were a judge, you have to have it innately.
You have to have an essential sense of "li", and there's no way of prescribing it.
This is the very devil for teachers.
Because you see, all our universities and schools are trying to teach creativity.
That's the great thing these days.
You know, and you hear at the Esalen, all sorts of people are giving courses and workshops
in creativity.
Now the trouble is this, if we found out a method whereby we could teach creativity,
and everybody could just explain how it was done, it would no longer be of interest.
What always is an essential element in the creative is the mysterious.
And so again and again in Taoist literature, you will find this character, Xuan, which
means the deep, the dark, it's like the black in lacquer.
The impenetrable, and yet the profound depth out of which glorious things come, but nobody
can see why.
This very much goes together with Tao.
When there's a place in the Lao Tzu book where he says that the spirit of the valley never
dies, well the spirit of the valley, the deep ravine, is this.
There's a poem which says that when the bird calls, the mountain becomes more mysterious.
You imagine for example you're in a mountain valley, and everything is very silent.
And suddenly a crow squawks somewhere.
You don't know where that crow is, and that little sound emphasizes the silence.
Silence becomes deeper and deeper.
Well this word is used for the kind of mysteriousness which that bird's call creates.
So these two words together are used in Japanese, the expression "Yuugen".
And "Yuugen" is a quality which the poet Soami, who was a great artist of the Noh plays, said
"Yuugen is to watch wild geese flying and be hidden in a cloud.
To watch ships sailing in the distance and to disappear behind a far off island.
To wander on and on in a great forest without thought of return."
Now all those things have in them, you see, an element of mystery.
There's a Chinese poem which puts it this way.
It is a poem written by a man who has gone to find a sage in the mountains.
And the sage has a little hut at the foot of the mountain and a boy there who is his
servant.
"I asked the boy beneath the pines.
He said the master's gone alone, herb gathering somewhere on the mount, cloud hidden, whereabouts
unknown."
And this also creates the mood of "Yuugen".
The hermit, you see, is a kind of "Yuugen" personality.
He's a very valuable person and a very wise person.
But nobody knows where he is.
And ever so many Chinese poems are concerned with the life of hermits, seeking after hermits,
and the wonder of hermits who totally disappear altogether.
There's this funny idea of the deep and the dark, the thing that is important just because
you can't quite understand it.
Now to Westerners, all that tends to sound rather hopeless.
You say, "If you can't tell us how it's done, what's the use?"
And that, you see, is because we have insufficient trust in ourselves.
We think that we'll never be able to do certain things unless we have instructions as to how
to do it.
This comes, of course, partly from our toilet training.
Mama gets anxious that it won't happen and starts making commandments about it.
And then you have to have courses.
One of the funniest stories I heard was somebody was in a hotel in Europe, in England somewhere,
and was going downstairs and suddenly there was a room, you know, where they have committee
meeting rooms, and there were a whole chorus of people saying, "We haven't today, but we
will tomorrow.
We haven't today, but we will tomorrow."
I said, "What on earth is that?"
Somebody said, "That is Dr. Kueh's constipation class."
The Taoist idea is not like that, you see.
Let it happen.
It will, trusting yourself, because your own organism fulfils these things spontaneously
of itself, and you don't have to force it.

a lecture on how thought and perception construct the world we take to be objectively given, followed by a survey of meditation methods for seeing past that construction.

an audiobook reading of watts's book the way of zen, narrated by ralph blum and interwoven with recordings of watts himself, tracing zen's taoist and buddhist roots through to its


